JMU education professors awarded for research on AI

In a rapidly evolving educational landscape, the integration of artificial intelligence tools such as ChatGPT into teaching practices offers both promising opportunities and significant challenges. This duality is exemplified by recent research conducted by Amanda Gantt Sawyer and Marcus Wolfe, professors at James Madison University's College of Education. Their work, which earned them the prestigious 2025 National Technology Leadership Initiative Fellowship, delves into how preservice teachers utilize AI in developing math curricula.

Focus on Form over Substance

The study reveals a concerning trend among future educators who prioritize the visual appeal of AI-generated materials over rigorous content analysis. This inclination towards aesthetics rather than substance raises critical questions about the preparedness of new teachers to effectively harness AI technologies in their pedagogical practices.

"Our findings underscore the urgent need for educators to not only embrace AI tools but also to engage in critical evaluation of the content these tools produce," said Amanda Gantt Sawyer, highlighting the core issue identified in their research.

The Imperative of Critical Evaluation

The research conducted by Sawyer and Wolfe highlights a fundamental gap in teacher education programs: the need to instill a critical mindset towards AI-generated educational materials. As AI becomes increasingly prevalent in classrooms, educators must develop the skills necessary to discern the quality and accuracy of AI outputs. Without this critical lens, there is a risk of perpetuating superficial learning experiences that prioritize appearance over educational value.

Broader Implications and Ethical Considerations

The findings from this research also prompt a broader discussion about the ethical implications of AI in education. As AI tools continue to shape the way curricula are developed and delivered, there is an urgent need for clear guidelines and policies that ensure these technologies are used responsibly. The potential for AI to enhance educational outcomes is vast, but without proper oversight, it could also exacerbate existing inequalities and undermine the integrity of educational systems.

Originally published at https://www.jmu.edu/news/2025/06/02-coe-ai-research.shtml

ResearchWize Editorial Insight

This article is crucial for students and researchers as it highlights the complex role of AI in education. The study by Sawyer and Wolfe at James Madison University underscores a critical issue: the tendency of preservice teachers to prioritize aesthetics over content when using AI tools. This raises questions about the effectiveness of current teacher training programs in preparing educators to critically assess AI-generated materials.

The research calls attention to the need for a critical mindset in evaluating AI outputs. As AI becomes ubiquitous in classrooms, the ability to discern quality and accuracy is vital. Without this skill, there's a risk of fostering superficial learning experiences that could undermine educational quality.

Moreover, the article touches on broader ethical implications. The unchecked use of AI in education could exacerbate inequalities and compromise educational integrity. This necessitates the development of clear policies and guidelines to ensure responsible AI use.

For students and researchers, the article serves as a call to action to explore how AI can be integrated into education without sacrificing substance for form. It also invites inquiry into the long-term impacts of AI on educational equity and quality. Are we equipping future educators with the tools they need to navigate this new landscape effectively?

Looking Ahead

1. AI Literacy as Core Curriculum AI literacy should become as fundamental as reading and arithmetic. Schools must prioritize teaching students and educators how AI works, its potential biases, and its limitations. But who will design these curricula? Are our educational leaders equipped to teach what they barely understand?

2. From Consumers to Creators We must transform students from passive consumers of AI-generated content into active creators. This shift requires robust programming and critical thinking modules. Can our current teacher training programs pivot quickly enough to produce educators who can guide this transformation?

3. Regulatory Frameworks: A Race Against Time Regulators must establish clear, enforceable guidelines for AI use in education before technology outpaces policy. What happens if regulators fall behind? Could we see an era where AI dictates educational content unchecked, shaping young minds with no oversight?

4. Ethical AI Integration Integrate ethics into AI education. Students should learn to question not just how AI functions, but why it makes certain decisions. This ethical grounding is crucial. Will educational institutions rise to the challenge of embedding ethics into tech education, or will they continue to treat it as an afterthought?

5. Equity and Access AI has the potential to democratize education, but only if access is equitable. Policymakers need to ensure that rural and underserved communities are not left behind in the AI education revolution. Will we see a widening education gap if this disparity isn't addressed?

6. Continuous Professional Development Educators must engage in ongoing professional development focused on AI tools and methodologies. This requires substantial investment and commitment. Are our educational systems prepared to allocate the necessary resources, or will they settle for a piecemeal approach?

7. Collaborative Ecosystems Foster collaborations between tech companies and educational institutions to ensure AI tools are developed with educational integrity at their core. But who will hold these partnerships accountable? Can we trust tech giants to prioritize education over profit?

Originally reported by https://www.jmu.edu/news/2025/06/02-coe-ai-research.shtml.

📌 Take the Next Step with ResearchWize

Want to supercharge your studying with AI? Install the ResearchWize browser extension today and unlock powerful tools for summaries, citations, and research organization.

Not sure yet? Learn more about how ResearchWize helps students succeed.